Welcome!

By registering with us, you'll be able to discuss, share and private message with other members of our community.

SignUp Now!

Black Mesa: INSULA Day One Feedback Thread

Omega

Forum Warrior
ENG
SS Manager
GALUNGA
Gamemaster
Staff Team
Joined
Sep 14, 2022
Messages
617
Thread is as titled. Feedback for day one of the event.
 
I thought it'd be better if the military held on for a little longer, but eh. Player Agency.
It was a really well built map, and it was perfect for what we were going for; not really a big fan of the huge Xenian alien battles though, those could go.
 
I wanted a least a bit of researchRP before everything went to absolute hell. There was no rhyme or reason to the aliens, either. Players had very little agency to affect the course of the story today. The constant NPCs kept everyone on the back foot and reacting, leaving very little room for proactive engagement.
 
I liked it and the in-danger dialogue going on, but there wasn't a lot of room to do much beyond that. It was mostly preparing people for the dangers and then the infighting. The character interactions have been fun but I'm not quite sure what we did in terms of progress aside from surviving.

I like.
 
I wanted a least a bit of researchRP before everything went to absolute hell. There was no rhyme or reason to the aliens, either. Players had very little agency to affect the course of the story today. The constant NPCs kept everyone on the back foot and reacting, leaving very little room for proactive engagement.
Alright, that's fair enough. Frankly when planning this event, I had assumed that leaving the storm to a later hour of the event would've been boring. However, I suppose I had underestimated y'all in how much you would really want to passive. This will be taken into account for Day Two, however.

On the randomness of the Portal Storm, I suppose I was trying to convey the lack of predictability of the world that exists after the Resonance Cascade. Could have had better build up to that, but like I mentioned earlier, I had assumed everyone would be eager for some action.
 
Loved it, a bit bummed I never got the chance to just pretend to fix up the base or get involved with an experiment or two. The interactions I had along the way of finding survivors though was cool, and getting a chance to talk to the vort at the end was fucking rad. Love vorts.
 
Not a researcher, but I do tend to agree with them that the portal storm was a bit on the abrupt side and not really in an immersive way. Overall, though, I did enjoy the military experience. It was not an easy fight to win and we were forced to work together, which was a huge plus. Be a little careful about using heavy use of screen shake effects, though, as I honestly did get a little nauseous.
 
Had lots of fun with the research jabbering. The storm lighting during the big scene in the cafeteria made things a little too dark to really see what was going on, but it kind of worked for such a confusing sequence.

Honestly think the first day peaked with the post-game passive scene. Got to do just a bit of Research RP at the end of a mostly tragic day.

I'd love to see what becomes of this research station in the end.
 
Honestly? While the storm was indeed a little too early, all things considered
It went well.
Talking to the vort though was dope as hell
Generally, the actual attacks perpetuated by the aliens were chaotic, but fun to a degree. If there's more passive to balance it out, I figure it'll do wonders.
More research, more stuff like that.

peak
 
I have to be honest, I’m pretty disappointed with how the event turned out, especially because I think there was real potential in the original idea.

When I learned about the concept, I thought "This is cool! Finally, an event that will let us do passive scientific roleplay, with experiments, expeditions, and interactions between researchers. " Given the number of scientists present, I genuinely thought that’s the direction the event was going to take.

Unfortunately, after an hour and a half of just wandering around the map in circles without really knowing what to do I finally managed to gather the scientists to organize the teams and start the experiments. Except that a portal storm broke out, with by about twenty NPC glitching through walls and knocking players out without really giving them a chance to react.

Then about two hours of combat spent wandering the map to shoot at Houndeyes. Once calm was here, we were approached by the military, and honestly, I didn’t understand a single thing about that scene. Everyone was shouting, people were running all over the place, and there talked about communists and Republicans… In short, it was mad confusing.

I think my disappointment is mainly from the gap between my expectations and how the event actually unfolded. I would have much preferred a first day of exploration, experiment, and the development of the scientific roleplay, perhaps with a few minor incidents to gradually build tension and give game to security and soldier, before the situation really goes brrr on the second and third days.

I also think there’s an issue with player guidance. I understand the concept of a "player-driven event", and I actually think it’s an good idea. But for it to work, you still need to provide some hints or objectives, even vague ones to allow players to build their roleplay around them. The point isn’t to leave them completely in the dark with the sole instruction, "Do whatever you want."

I know that organizing an event takes time and I’m not trying to destroy the organizers, but I think it’s a shame that a storyline with so much potential is being wasted day one just for the sake of shooting shooting shooting
 
I actually really liked it. Like pretty much no bad things on my end.

I'll start with the cons since I've got more to say about them, but keep in mind that overall they were actually very miniscule to the overall experience.

Cons:

1. The introduction was very hectic and the tour broke down pretty fast. My issue with is that mostly that we didn't get to introduce ourselves to the rest of the technician and the security teams (although they might've just not been on at that time). I think it took some effect out of the rendezvous we had after the first batch of teleportations since there were guys I haven't seen during the intro (but I guess it was sort of realistic in that way).

Some people have talked about the lack of passive before shit hit the fan, but I honestly don't really mind it. Perhaps there should've been more non-work passive time (like talking with your coworkers in the cafeteria), but immediately starting research projects off the bat just to have them immediately cut down by the portal storms would've been a pretty bad idea imo. Then again, I suppose that would depend on what stage of research everything would've gone to hell.

So, in short, a little more time to get to know each other in depth would've been good.

2. NPC spam early on was kinda a big meh. I liked the general implementation of the whole facility invasion thing, but having a panthereye just spawn out of the blue in the room with all the people was pretty wacky. It just felt a little too overwhelming to have all of the NPCs show up in every crevice near you. And less "holy shit what's happening" type of overwhelming and more like "im genuinely getting shot from every fucking angle" type.

3. I think the vort stuff came in too early. We found a non-antagonistic vort and managed to do some basic communicating (not without proper caution). But I think already having a friendly vort on day 1 is kinda too wild. At times we've also probably pushed too far with logical connections (I suppose I've got blame in that too).

4. Not really sure about this one, but since I think everyone was pretty much doing passive at the second part of the event (like we were doing with the vortigaunts, and everyone else was having a Mexican standoff?), was there actually much left to even do in the facility? I suppose what I'm getting at is that, since we didn't have much of a goal to work towards except just to survive, it felt like after all the supplies were looted, there just sorta was nothing else to do but just passive. Obviously, that isn't a bad thing, I just think there could've been some interesting objectives mixed into the whole ordeal to spice things up, like maybe fix a generator for the failing power system, or try to fix a relay to contact the battleship, and etc. Perhaps those were always options, and we just didn't have to fall back on them since we really got into passive. So, not really a con, I suppose, just wondering if there could've been more to focus on objective wise.

Pros:

1. I liked the portal storms sequence quite a lot. At first, I absolutely hated it since I thought it was just one of those "don't get bored, here's your 5 mins of S2K!" moments, but then it kept going and turned into an actual survival scenario instead of just a shooting gallery. The whole teleporting players bit was a great way to cut us up into smaller groups, and the first thirty minutes after that really felt like we were trying to survive in the facility.

2. The overall mood after the portal storms was just great. Seeing your coworkers show up bloodied, trying to find a safe spot to move the wounded, hearing screams from the marines' radios -- overall very nice and really brought that Unforeseen Consequences energy.

3. The map seems pretty good overall. It is a bit laggy for me in certain parts but has a very nice mood to it. The facility was very fun to explore, especially the vents. I quite like the sort of bunker places that open up to the sea, letting you see the effect of the storms.

4. I think it was Rad that played the vortigaunt (I'm not sure), but the interactions were rather nice. As I said, I do feel that having a link to a friendly vortigaunt on day 1 is kinda too quick, but the roleplay itself was pretty good.

5. Overall, I felt that everything influenced my character, Dr. Warren, pretty heavily (which is good). There were no points where I'd OOCly go "oh come on" and lose the IC steam. Interactions were good, it felt like my char did have some say in some matters, and overall, I really liked how everything turned out.

6. I think this one is really personalised and definitely doesn't apply to everyone, but throughout day one I basically never had to call a GM for anything. There just wasn't really any need to. Everything just sort of flowed naturally. Obviously, it's probably because I didn't encounter any situations where a GM was required, but it's still a pretty big plus -- no need to wait and bring yourself out of the IC experience. Big thumbs up for the event keeping me entertained just by the happenings of it alone.

7. I do actually think having Research be done after the portal storms was the right call. I think having it before without any stakes would've been rather boring. Of course, there could've been possibilities of getting specimens from the caves and yada yada, but live research during an alien attack, barely any resources left? That just feels like a lot more of an interesting scenario to me that just casual cubicle research.

So yeah, my subjective score is 4/5. Good stuff.
 
Last edited:
Bit of a late post, but I have the time to write down my thoughts.

I tend to agree with others that the portal storms felt abrupt while everyone wanted to do some passive RP for a bit before shit hits the fan.

The only gripe I had was the small issue of me lying dying on the ground for almost fifteen minutes after the portalstorms, I was considering killing off my character at that point since having him alive would feel silly after lying on the floor dying for quite a bit.

I enjoyed propping up the lab, doing some passive and theory crafting with other eggheads about the alien lifeforms.

Not much else from me, good work!
 
Last edited:
I must say in retrospect I liked the event. While the quietness was indeed short-lived, where I was able to interact with a few people before chaos ensued. I valued the little moments we had of passive and interactive RP during the facility tour, the little bits of conversations, before all went to hell.

I like that we experienced the unpredictability that comes from portal storms and that they are much more intense than probably anyone would have thought they'd be like. Yes, it scattered the group and for me personally, through FearRP, my character came to different conclusions in the end than she would've gotten if it was a regular, casual day at the facility.

Furthermore, the portal storms and all that have given us new ground for continued RP, which I did very much appreciate. While it sometimes seemed not as coherent, it did (in my opinion) give us an image how hectic situations like this in real life would also (possibly) play out.

I look forward to what follows in the next hours.
 
Back
Top