Welcome!

By registering with us, you'll be able to discuss, share and private message with other members of our community.

SignUp Now!

Black Mesa: INSULA - Day Three/Overall Feedback Thread

Omega

Forum Warrior
ENG
SS Manager
GALUNGA
Gamemaster
Staff Team
Joined
Sep 14, 2022
Messages
617
Tell me what you thought about it all, please. This was my first event on Willard ever, so I am very much open to receiving feedback! :)
 
My feedback on the other Days remain the same.

Day 3, I think was put together quite well. I like the science bits and assisting with the relay RP.

I am just not a fan of S2K, as always. I was in the middle of typing right when I got shot by a spear. Always unpleasant.

I think the remaining characters and their drama is very on-point and real.

I am not quite sure what the relay's actual effect was and whether we did it, and I'm not sure what alternative routes we could've taken.
 
Honestly? I'd say I'd rate this pretty good.

Mainly the thing out of this whole event that I liked was the way proper discussions, when there wasn't chaos, flowed proper, like discussing some of the xenian wildlife in the hydroponics, for example

Main thing's the way the synths came in, and a lot of it genuinely got me in that sort of 'foreboding' way.
Great telling of the scene, honestly.

While I don't know the far reaching effect of the relay, seeing it actually work was dope.

Also, those synth spears were horrifying
 


1794783199101.png

1794783212970.png

1794783303279.png

1794783349358.png
1794783448749.png
1794783462503.png
1794783533772.png
1794783548389.png
1794783608657.png
1794783633668.png
1794783658120.png
1794783688571.png
1794783703142.png
1794783722316.png
1794783890542.png
1794783921321.png
1794783967095.png
1794784027619.png
1794784075840.png
1794784123989.png
1794784163879.png
 

Attachments

  • 1794783260614.png
    1794783260614.png
    8.1 MB · Views: 0
  • 1794783312026.png
    1794783312026.png
    7.2 MB · Views: 0
  • 1794783431035.png
    1794783431035.png
    10.8 MB · Views: 0
  • 1794783577695.png
    1794783577695.png
    10.3 MB · Views: 0
  • 1794783624213.png
    1794783624213.png
    4.9 MB · Views: 0
  • 1794783648003.png
    1794783648003.png
    9.1 MB · Views: 0
  • 1794784011533.png
    1794784011533.png
    6.7 MB · Views: 0
I wasn't able to make it today, but I have some general critiques for the event overall, (and roleplay events in general), that I think would make the next event even more enjoyable. Mainly, I think goals and the available methods of achieving those goals should be more readily known. I'll give a couple examples:

1. Scientists had a general goal of studying Xen life and combating it. But, how were we expected to do this? Did we have any specific scientific equipment to speak of? Were there specific opportunities for research that we missed out on?

2. Spies. We had a general idea of obtaining information, but what information was important and why? Did we have specific objectives to work towards? Wigglesworth was an Aperture spy, but his only given objective was to cause a "breach." What were some ways he could have done this?

Now, I know the most likely response to this critique. It's that you don't want to engage in hand-holding and would rather the players make their own paths. I understand that, BUT... At a certain level, lack of direction is more frustrating than anything. Concrete goals and methods make the experience much less confusing and more enjoyable for everyone. At least, that's my philosophy on the matter when it comes to roleplay server events.
 
Wasn't able to make the final day, but despite for all the shortcomings I still had a decent amount of fun.

Like mentioned before a small gripe is that a majority of us were rather aimless, with no other goal rather than just 'existing', the possibility of spies wasn't even something I even remotely considered if I'm being frank, simply because there was nothing to protect other than the staff. Sure there was the facility, but what am I protecting here, PLANTS?

I wasn't able to play into the more mercenary nature of my char, though I doubt there would've been many opportunities into the first place, so thats fine with me.

Also, security imploding on day 2 be like:
 
This shit was great, would've loved some more time to get to know each character, had time to develop the story a little more, and be given some free space to have run actual experiments or done some engineering before it all went to hell, but aside from that, amazing.
 
Back
Top