Complaint on Goose

[Oebelysk]

Topic/subject: Being beaten to near death with no roleplay
Whom it may concern: @Imperator GOOSE-X on his CP
Summary: I walk to rations through the front entrance and am told to leave, so I do so. I then walk to rations through the back entrance and begin to collect my ration. A scanner takes a picture of me, and before I can collect my ration that has been distributed, I am knocked out with a stunbaton with no roleplay or time to react and am then beaten to a third of my health. My ration is then stolen and I die from dehydration on the sidewalk.
In depth analysis of the issue: Logs can show that there was zero interaction between my character and the Civil Protection unit.
Suggestion for improvement: Follow the rules, doesn't matter if you are a faction leader or a senior staff member

This isn't exactly related, but the quality of Civil Protection on the server really seems to be lacking. What is this?
*** [Another grunt of Civil Protection, th...] jabs his baton into the man's stomach.
*** [Another grunt of Civil Protection, th...] jabs his baton into the man's stomach.
*** [Another grunt of Civil Protection, th...] jabs his baton into the man's stomach.
*** [Another grunt of Civil Protection, th...] jabs his baton into the man's stomach.
*** [Another grunt of Civil Protection, th...] jabs his baton into the man's stomach.

just spamming the same /me over and over, come on now

 

[Goose]

Tagging @SifTheAI due to involvement.
I'll admit, there wasn't any roleplay. This is because civil protection is allowed to do so in these circumstances. You ran past CP's without any RP, which is the exact scenario in order for CP's to do that. I probably shouldn't have beaten you on the ground, but the knock out was entirely justified when you surpassed us with any RP yourself.

That's all from me, I'll respond to this thread only if need be.

 

[Oebelysk]

Tagging @SifTheAI due to involvement.
I'll admit, there wasn't any roleplay. This is because civil protection is allowed to do so in these circumstances. You ran past CP's without any RP, which is the exact scenario in order for CP's to do that. I probably shouldn't have beaten you on the ground, but the knock out was entirely justified when you surpassed us with any RP yourself.

That's all from me, I'll respond to this thread only if need be.

I didn't run past anyone. I went through the apartments to get into the ration center and saw no one.

 

[SifTheAI]

Hi there.

I was watching in observer. From what I saw, you blatantly ignore the barricades and Civil Protection in front of the RDT and run through apartments to get to the ration machine, without providing any roleplay as you did so. This resulted in a scanner declaring you as unlawfully entering, and Goose responded by stunning you with no roleplay, due to your own lack of roleplay. I cannot speak on the actual reasoning for the beating, other than presuming it was a standard punishment for your unlawful entry ICly. Your death by dehydration was an unfortunate and likely unintended side effect.

From my perspective, Goose was justified in performing a non-roleplay attack to his viewing of you avoiding the roleplay of the ration queue, however it is true that neither of you provided roleplay for that encounter; you with your running past of CP and Goose with his stunning of you. In my opinion, I'd suggest to just shake hands and move on in this instance.

 

[Oebelysk]

Hi there.

I was watching in observer. From what I saw, you blatantly ignore the barricades and Civil Protection in front of the RDT and run through apartments to get to the ration machine, without providing any roleplay as you did so. This resulted in a scanner declaring you as unlawfully entering, and Goose responded by stunning you with no roleplay, due to your own lack of roleplay. I cannot speak on the actual reasoning for the beating, other than presuming it was a standard punishment for your unlawful entry ICly. Your death by dehydration was an unfortunate and likely unintended side effect.

From my perspective, Goose was justified in performing a non-roleplay attack to his viewing of you avoiding the roleplay of the ration queue, however it is true that neither of you provided roleplay for that encounter; you with your running past of CP and Goose with his stunning of you. In my opinion, I'd suggest to just shake hands and move on in this instance.

...what roleplay am I supposed to perform walking from point A to B with no one in my way? Yes, I ignored the barricades in front of the RDT by taking a different path with zero Civil Protection or barricades on the path there. That doesn't at all justify being walked up to, knocked out, and beaten without any roleplay. I didn't walk past anyone.

Do you want me to /me walking next time?

 

[Oebelysk]

 

[Goose]

Then in my case, I owe you an apology.

From my perspective, you had simply run by us without roleplay. While rules in this scenario still allows CP's to stun stick without RP, I'll agree I should've RPed it here.